Cardano‘s decentralized representatives (DReps) have voted to reject a request from Toto Finance seeking 22 million ADA, valued at approximately $3.3 million, from the Cardano treasury for a project aiming to establish a “Strategic Copper Reserve.”
Majority vote blocks copper investment plan
The voting process, which concluded on November 15, saw DReps holding 2.86 billion ADA cast their ballots against Toto Finance’s proposal. In comparison, only DReps with a combined 20.02 million ADA voted in favor.
DReps are elected representatives within the Cardano ecosystem who participate in on-chain governance decisions that impact the project’s treasury and major initiatives. Their votes reflect both community sentiment and risk assessment.
John MacPherson, a Cardano DRep who opposed the proposal, stated publicly that he is not inherently against the integration of real-world assets on Cardano. However, he argued that the proposal would require the treasury to assume the price risks of both copper and ADA while allowing Toto Finance to potentially collect up to 3.4 million ADA in fees.
MacPherson expressed concerns that the treasury “would take on both the copper price and the ADA price,” and noted that Toto Finance stood to collect significant fees under the proposed structure. Nevertheless, he acknowledged that the proposal was “more honest about its risks than most.”
Toto Finance’s strategic copper reserve proposal
Led by CEO Monty Metzger, Toto Finance submitted the plan on October 15. At the current ADA price of $0.152, the 22 million ADA requested equates to roughly $3.3 million.
According to Toto Finance, the plan involved using 14.72 million ADA to purchase copper and storing the metal in a warehouse near New Orleans. The company intended to issue a CuTT token for every pound of copper acquired and projected that the metal would be sold off within an 18 to 24-month period.
Mini dictionary: CuTT token — A digital token proposed by Toto Finance, designed to represent ownership of one pound of copper in a strategic reserve. Such asset-backed tokens aim to bring real-world commodities onto blockchain platforms for trading and proof of custody.
The Cardano Foundation, which also participates in decision-making as a DRep, publicly confirmed its opposition to the initiative in October. The foundation cited the lack of established safeguards and concerns about concentration of control and high fees.
The Cardano Foundation warned that the proposal would place “22,000,000 ADA under the recipient’s sole control to fund a fee-heavy concentrated commodity position whose safeguards are not yet in place.”
Within the Constitutional Committee, responsible for overseeing certain aspects of Cardano’s governance, three members voted against the proposal, while the remaining four abstained from voting.
Community perspectives and risk considerations
Ingeniero Cripto, a well-known commentator in the crypto community, supported MacPherson’s view by emphasizing the dual risk exposure for the treasury. He argued that because Cardano’s treasury already holds ADA, adding exposure to copper prices increases potential risk, making the proposal less attractive for community funding.
While both Ingeniero Cripto and MacPherson acknowledged the broader potential of real-world asset (RWA) tokenization on Cardano, they clarified that funding the asset itself differs significantly from investing in the infrastructure to support such assets.
Toto Finance’s initiative highlights ongoing debates around onboarding real-world commodities to blockchain networks and the specific structures that community treasuries are willing to support.
| Proposal | Requested ADA | Value (USD) | Votes For | Votes Against |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Toto Finance Strategic Copper Reserve | 22 million ADA | $3.3 million | 20.02 million ADA | 2.86 billion ADA |






