Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin stated that he now supports the leanPCS approach for EIP-8288, a draft Ethereum Improvement Proposal designed to help the blockchain handle the much larger signatures required for quantum-resistant cryptography without overloading network capacity.
Buterin’s shift in stance
In recent comments published on X, Buterin shared that his view on the leanPCS method has changed significantly. He remarked, “Over the past few weeks I’ve gone from thinking leanPCS is total bull to being a total bull.” This shift signals his endorsement of leanPCS as the preferred solution for managing future cryptographic proof systems in Ethereum.
Over the past few weeks I’ve gone from thinking leanPCS is total bull to being a total bull.
Buterin explained that the leanPCS approach, which stands for polynomial commitment scheme, requires only the selection of a mathematical field and allows Ethereum to efficiently verify a STARK—a type of zero-knowledge proof recognized for its scalability—for an estimated 20,000 to 40,000 gas.
EIP-8288, co-authored by Buterin and computer scientist Thomas Coratger in June, proposes a mechanism for handling signatures and proofs that could, in the quantum era, be as large as 128 kilobytes each. This change is crucial because existing Ethereum signatures use ECDSA, which are 65 bytes, whereas quantum-safe hash-based signatures require 1 to 6 kilobytes, and quantum-safe zero-knowledge proofs could be much larger.
Reducing on-chain burden
The draft proposal would move verification of these signatures and proofs from the main blockchain to the mempool, where pending transactions are kept. Instead of placing the hefty cryptographic proofs on chain, nodes would check them in the mempool and then combine them into recursive STARKs. As a result, each block would need to include only a single, aggregated proof, while only essential information, like the matching of public keys and messages, would be recorded on chain.
This approach targets a major scalability problem as Ethereum looks to adopt stronger, quantum-resistant cryptography in the coming years.
Alternative options and technical hurdles
Buterin compared leanPCS to two alternatives. The first, leanSPHINCS, is a single quantum-safe hash-based signature scheme. SPHINCS+—standardized in 2024 by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) as SLH-DSA—underpins this approach. Buterin noted that installing leanSPHINCS would allow users to maintain quantum-safe accounts while controlling gas fees. Signature verification could cost 4,096 gas for 64 bytes on Ethereum, but leanSPHINCS is limited to this one specific scheme. Research cited by Buterin found that, even today, a smart contract can validate a SPHINCS+ signature for about 94,000 to 276,000 gas, depending on the NIST-set parameters.
Mini dictionary: SPHINCS+ is a stateless hash-based signature scheme designed to offer strong resistance to quantum computing attacks. In 2024, the US National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) selected it as the basis for the SLH-DSA (Stateless Hash-based Digital Signature Algorithm) standard, setting new benchmarks for post-quantum secure signatures.
| Scheme | Type | Verification Gas (approx.) | Flexibility |
|---|---|---|---|
| leanPCS | Polynomial commitment | 20,000–40,000 | Any proof type via STARKs |
| leanSPHINCS | Hash-based signature | 4,096 (single signature), 94,000–276,000 (smart contract) | SPHINCS+ only |
| leanSTARK | Zero-knowledge proof | Not specified (ISA-dependent) | Any computation, once ISA set |
The third option, leanSTARK, would accept proofs for any computation, but only after Ethereum finalizes its instruction set architecture (ISA). This development, according to Buterin, will take more time because “it’s a really big deal” and consensus on the details must be reached. If and when that happens, leanSTARK could be implemented at a later stage.
Industry response and outlook
Buterin called leanPCS “a path to the cryptographic proof singularity,” believing it could be achieved more quickly than earlier anticipated.
Starknet, an Ethereum Layer 2 network built by StarkWare, has considered transitioning into a Layer 1 blockchain to pursue quantum resistance, with StarkWare CEO Eli Ben-Sasson cautioning that the quantum computing threat could arrive sooner than the industry expects.
EIP-8288 remains a draft, and its adoption would require a network-wide upgrade to bring these technical changes into effect.
Buterin views leanPCS as a direct solution to the scaling challenges posed by quantum-safe signatures and has argued it could enable the rapid adoption of more advanced cryptographic techniques across the Ethereum ecosystem.






