Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, brothers who studied at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, have been acquitted on all federal charges stemming from a high-profile $25 million Ethereum exploit in 2023. The ruling was delivered by U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke in a Manhattan federal court, bringing the case to a close without a retrial.
Acquittal Follows Mistrial, Scrutiny of Wire Fraud Elements
Judge Clarke cleared the brothers of conspiracy, wire fraud, and conspiracy to commit money laundering after prosecutors failed to provide evidence of a material misrepresentation, a required component for a wire fraud conviction.
A previous trial ended in November 2025 with a mistrial, as the jury could not reach a verdict. The defense successfully challenged the prosecution’s assertion that the brothers’ actions amounted to wire fraud.
Clarke stated that Ethereum operates in a “trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use,” concluding that the government had not proven its case regarding the alleged fraud.
She further remarked that while the defendants’ plan “may have frustrated the spirit” of MEV-Boost software, that alone did not constitute fraud under U.S. law.
Due to the outcome on the fraud charges, the related money laundering counts were also dismissed, as these relied on the fraudulent origin of funds.
The $25 Million Ethereum MEV Exploit Explained
The case originated from an incident in April 2023, in which the brothers were accused of targeting so-called “sandwich bots.” These bots are automated traders designed to maximize profits from maximal extractable value (MEV) strategies, typically by inserting their trades before and after those of other users, often at the expense of smaller market participants.
Prosecutors claimed Anton and James used bait transactions to attract such bots and then exploited a vulnerability in relay software code, enabling them to view the bots’ bundled trades before finalizing a block. They swapped the bait with sales, locking in profits and causing losses estimated at $25 million within a 12-second window.
Authorities arrested both individuals in May 2024 following a lengthy investigation. Prosecutors argued that the operation required considerable planning and deliberate steps to conceal the resulting funds.
Mini dictionary: MEV-Boost — MEV-Boost is open-source software that allows Ethereum network validators to outsource block construction to specialized block builders. This system seeks to maximize the value that validators can extract from new blocks, though it can also be exploited by actors using advanced trading strategies.
Industry Impact and Legal Significance
The trial was regarded as a significant test case within the cryptocurrency sector. Legal experts and industry participants closely watched the outcome, as the charges represented the first time U.S. authorities attempted to apply traditional criminal fraud statutes to activity related to on-chain trading exploits.
Clarke described the prosecution as “first of its kind,” a perspective also emphasized by the government’s original indictment. The acquittal underscores the legal complexity of pursuing fraud charges in blockchain-based financial systems, where technical exploits often operate in regulatory gray areas.
Clarke noted that “the question before the Court is not whether the Peraire-Buenos’ conduct was right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes,” but whether “the government proved its case.”






