Customers of failed crypto exchanges often face substantial losses, finding themselves at the end of lengthy bankruptcy proceedings with little chance of recovering their digital assets. Senator Cynthia Lummis, a leading advocate for the CLARITY Act, has stated that her proposed legislation would address this ongoing issue.
The bankruptcy risk for crypto customers
Senator Lummis emphasized that the risks are not merely hypothetical. In the event of an exchange bankruptcy, customers are typically required to line up behind lawyers and institutional creditors, who have higher priority. As a result, users may only reclaim a small portion of their holdings, if anything at all.
Senator Cynthia Lummis pointed out that, “When a crypto exchange goes bankrupt today, customers are forced to get in line behind lawyers and creditors with low priority in hopes of maybe recouping a fraction of their assets. The CLARITY Act ensures consumers’ assets are protected just like they would be with traditional institutions.”
Senator Lummis serves as a member of the U.S. Senate Banking Committee and has long advocated for regulatory clarity in the crypto sector.
Major collapses highlight urgent need
Several high-profile crypto exchange failures, most notably the collapse of FTX in November 2022, have underscored this problem. Customers of FTX reportedly lost billions of dollars, as bankruptcy courts classified client funds as part of the exchange’s estate. This treatment left individual users competing with large institutional creditors over the remaining assets.
ETH
SOL
BSC
ROBINHOOD
USDT
AAPLSimilar situations occurred at other platforms such as Celsius, Voyager, and BlockFi, revealing that crypto users lack the legal protections afforded to traditional investors. Under current securities law, assets held by customers at licensed brokers are separated from company property, ensuring investors are prioritized during insolvency. No such mechanism currently exists for digital assets.
How the CLARITY Act would change the rules
The proposed CLARITY Act aims to categorize digital commodities as customer property within the U.S. Bankruptcy Code, granting crypto customers rights comparable to those of holders of stocks or commodities. The bill would require exchanges and brokers to hold client assets at specialized custodians, entirely separate from their operating funds. Any commingling of client and company assets, the kind that contributed to the FTX collapse, would be prohibited.
Key portions of the legislation link digital commodities to existing bankruptcy protections applicable to other kinds of commodity contracts. The goal is to move customers to the front of the line in any bankruptcy distribution.
Mini dictionary: CLARITY Act – Proposed United States legislation designed to create clear rules for the treatment of customer digital asset holdings during crypto exchange bankruptcies, prioritizing customer recovery above other creditors.
| Bankruptcy Scenario | Traditional Securities | Crypto Assets (Current) | Crypto Assets (With CLARITY Act) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Customer Fund Priority | First | Last | First |
| Asset Segregation Requirement | Mandatory | Not required | Mandatory |
| Custodian Standards | Regulated Broker-Dealers | Varies by platform | Qualified digital custodians |
Legislative outlook and next steps
Senator Lummis has championed the CLARITY Act for several years. She has stated that if the bill does not pass during the current congressional session, regulatory progress on digital assets could be delayed until at least 2030. The Senate is set to hold a crucial cloture vote on September 15, marking a key juncture for the bill’s advancement.
The Senator has warned that failure to enact the CLARITY Act could postpone comprehensive crypto safeguards for years, highlighting the urgency for legislative action.
Should the legislation clear the Senate, delays in the House of Representatives remain possible, although Republican leadership is reportedly pushing to deliver the bill to the President soon.
Implications for XRP and digital asset holders
XRP holders and the broader crypto community are closely following the bill’s progress, as the CLARITY Act would offer the first federal legal framework ensuring digital asset owners cannot be subordinated behind creditors in insolvency cases. If enacted, the legislation would fundamentally strengthen legal protections for crypto customers in the United States.
With the Senate vote on the horizon, the outcome is expected to set a precedent for future exchange bankruptcies and potentially reshape recovery processes for digital asset holders.
